Exploring Haunted Maine: Inns, Theatres, Forts, Lighthouses, & More
Would you like to save this full guide?
We'll email this article to you, so you can come back to it later!
There’s something about Maine that seems to invite ghosts to linger. Maybe it’s the endless stretch of fog rolling in off the Atlantic, the salt-stained shingles of centuries-old homes, or the steady blink of lighthouses watching over rocky harbors.
Whatever the cause, the Pine Tree State is filled with tales of spirits that refuse to leave the places they once called home.
Autumn is the perfect time to lean into the mystery. Crisp nights, crackling fireplaces, and the crunch of fallen leaves make a stay in one of Maine’s historic inns — or a twilight visit to a lighthouse — the kind of experience that will have you listening for footsteps in empty hallways.
Maine Inns Where History Refuses to Rest
Maine’s inns are as much about history as they are hospitality. Many of these cozy hideaways have welcomed travelers for centuries, which means they’ve also collected stories — some sweet, others sorrowful.
Guests today often discover they’re not the only ones enjoying a night’s stay. From Kennebunk to Bar Harbor, these inns are said to harbor spirits who never checked out.
The Kennebunk Inn – Kennebunk
Once a tavern, stagecoach stop, and even a jail, this 1799 inn carries layers of history. According to reports collected by VisitMaine.net and local staff, glasses sometimes slide across counters without reason, and phantom footsteps echo upstairs.
Some believe a clerk and former owner remain behind, tending to their duties long after death.
James Fairfield House – Kennebunkport
Captain James Fairfield built his Federal-style home in 1813 after surviving imprisonment during the War of 1812. Though he died young, guests still whisper that his presence lingers.
Travel writers like Yankee Magazine have noted stories of visitors sensing a watchful but non-threatening spirit in the halls.
Did You Know? Today, the mansion is part of the Kennebunkport Captains Collection, a resort-style group of historic ship captains’ homes in Kennebunkport. The collection combines nautical charm with modern amenities, offering everything from private cottages to cozy rooms on landscaped grounds.
The Tides Beach Club – Goose Rocks Beach, Kennebunkport
Goose Rocks Beach is beloved for its beauty — and its stories. Locals jokingly call it “Goose Bumps Beach,” citing tales of Emma, the inn’s 19th-century owner, making ghostly appearances at this formerly named Tides by the Sea.
The legend has been passed down in Kennebunkport ghost walks and remains part of the inn’s folklore.
Nathaniel Lord Mansion – Kennebunkport
Built in 1812 but never enjoyed by Captain Nathaniel Lord himself, this inn is steeped in romantic tragedy. Guests have long reported seeing a woman in Victorian dress in the Lincoln bedroom, thought to be the captain’s wife.
The story is so well-known that it’s included in the Kennebunkport Historical Society’s oral histories.
Museums of Old York – York
The Old York Historical Society acknowledges the legend of a “white witch” drifting through the old Town Hall.
Docents and visitors alike have described cold spots and unexplained sightings, making this museum a stop for both history buffs and ghost hunters.
Admiral Peary Inn – Fryeburg
Known for hearty breakfasts and friendly hospitality, this inn is also said to be home to “Annabelle,” a ghostly child whose presence has been mentioned in Maine Ghosts and Legends anthologies. Guests claim to hear her laughter or catch glimpses of her darting across rooms.
Watchtide by the Sea – Searsport
Though now closed, this inn overlooking Penobscot Bay was once rumored to be plagued by hauntings. Former guests told stories of shadowy figures and slamming doors, accounts preserved on VisitMaine.net and local lore blogs.
The Lindsey Guest House – Rockland
Travelers have shared tales of doors slamming and beds shifting on their own in this 19th-century captain’s home. These accounts appear in regional ghost tours and have become part of Rockland’s haunted reputation.
Berry Manor Inn – Rockland
Known today for its famous homemade pies, Berry Manor Inn is also rumored to host three Victorian-era lady spirits. The story is often mentioned in Rockland travel features, blending sweet hospitality with spooky charm.
LimeRock Inn – Rockland
Formerly the home of a physician, this inn carries a darker legend: Patients from long ago still wander the halls. Guests have reported shadowy figures in stairwells, a story repeated in Maine Ghosts and Legends collections.
East Wind Inn – Tenant’s Harbor
Overlooking the harbor, this inn is a peaceful getaway — except for unexplained flickering lights and voices in empty rooms. According to local ghost tours, spirits are said to roam the upper floors.
Coach Stop Inn – Bar Harbor
Established in 1804, the Coach Stop Inn welcomes visitors with country charm. Yet staff and guests sometimes hear childlike laughter or experience locked doors that no one touched. These tales are part of Bar Harbor’s well-circulated ghost stories.
Lucerne Inn – Dedham
Bangor Daily News archives confirm a murder-suicide at this inn, a tragedy that seeded its haunted reputation. Guests describe cold drafts and shadows in the halls, reported in both newspaper features and paranormal tours.
The Greenville Inn & Cottages – Moosehead Lake
A graceful lady in period dress is said to drift through rooms, accompanied by phantom tap-dancing and voices. Accounts of her presence appear in Moosehead Lake folklore and local travel writing, often described as friendly rather than frightening.
Stages and Strongholds With a Past
While many ghost stories cling to homes and inns, Maine’s theaters and forts are equally alive with lore.
Playhouses that once rang with laughter and applause now echo with footsteps long after the curtain falls, and centuries-old fortresses still seem to hold onto the cries of those who fought — and died — on their grounds.
Ogunquit Playhouse – Ogunquit
Founded in 1933, the playhouse is a summer theater staple. Staff and performers have reported flickering lights, voices backstage, and footsteps on empty stages. These tales have been documented in Seacoast Online features and continue to intrigue theatergoers.
Biddeford City Theatre – Biddeford
Opened in 1896, this ornate theatre has seen fire and rebirth. Maine Ghost Hunters report that actors often feel unseen presences nearby, with unexplained cold spots and phantom applause lingering after shows.
The Opera House – Boothbay Harbor
Renovated to its former glory, this opera house is said to have stubborn spirits who tamper with instruments or voices heard when no one is inside. Local arts coverage and paranormal tours both mention these happenings.
Fort William Henry – Bristol
Colonial records confirm that Chief Taukolexis was hanged here in 1696. Visitors have since reported eerie cries and feelings of being watched. The PenBay Pilot has featured this fort in its roundups of haunted Maine sites.
Lighthouses and Legends at Sea
Lighthouses are among the most romantic and eerie places in Maine. They stand at the edge of the known world, surrounded by stormy seas and endless fog.
For generations, keepers and their families lived in isolation, facing danger daily — and sometimes tragedy. It’s no wonder so many of Maine’s lighthouses are wrapped in stories of restless spirits who refuse to let the lights go dark.
Boon Island Light – York
At 133 feet, Maine’s tallest lighthouse has a grim history. Shipwreck survivors turned to cannibalism here in the 1710s, a fact recorded in colonial accounts.
Later, as WJBQ Portland and New England lighthouse historians note, a grieving keeper’s wife reportedly lost her mind in isolation. Sailors still tell of a woman’s silhouette pacing in the lantern during fog.
Seguin Island Light – Georgetown
According to American Ghost Walks and repeated in countless travel guides, a keeper – maddened by his wife’s constant piano playing – killed her and himself. Though the piano was removed long ago, visitors and lighthouse volunteers say faint notes still drift through the air.
Wood Island Light – Biddeford
Historical records confirm that, in 1896, a tenant shot his landlord before turning the gun on himself. Since then, keepers have reported locked doors, moaning sounds, and shadowy figures. The story is preserved in New England Lighthouses: A Virtual Guide and local lore.
Owls Head Light – Rockland
Not all hauntings are ominous. PenBay Pilot reports that locals believe a former keeper still tends the light, and “The Little Lady” appears in the keeper’s house kitchen. Her presence is described as protective, adding to the lighthouse’s mystique.
Matinicus Rock Light – Matinicus Island
One of Maine’s most remote stations, this lighthouse has been linked in PenBay Pilot features to a keeper who hanged himself in the tower. Since then, doors slam and phantom footsteps echo through empty rooms.
Marshall Point Light – Port Clyde
Famous for its cameo in “Forrest Gump,” Marshall Point has a darker legend. Local lore tells of Ben Bennet, a teen murdered by rumrunners, whose ghost wanders the grounds. This story is shared in American Ghost Walks and coastal folklore.
Cape Elizabeth Light – Cape Elizabeth
In 1934, keeper Joseph Upton fell to his death here, and witnesses say his spirit still patrols the tower. Offshore, the wreck of the Charles, which killed Lydia Carver (known as the “Lady in White”), has given rise to sightings of a bride wandering the shore.
Both tragedies are confirmed in historical records and frequently retold in lighthouse histories.
Portland Head Light – Cape Elizabeth
Perhaps Maine’s most iconic lighthouse, Portland Head is said to host the spirits of past keepers like Barzillai Delano and Joshua Strout. Visitors have reported hearing bootsteps on the spiral stairs — stories often included in New England Lighthouses publications.
Why Maine’s Ghost Stories Endure
Ghost stories in Maine are less about horror and more about history. They’re the shipwrecked widows who never found peace, the keepers whose duty carried beyond death, and the children and townsfolk who left their mark.
Exploring these places — whether walking through a centuries-old fort, spending a night in a Victorian bedchamber, or climbing the spiral stairs of a lighthouse — isn’t just about chasing scares. It’s about feeling the weight of time – the echo of lives lived on the edge of sea and wilderness.
So, if you’re looking for a fall adventure that’s more spine-tingling than pumpkin-spiced, Maine’s haunted inns and lighthouses might just give you both. Book a room, bring a flashlight, and remember: The stories are part of the experience.